Skip to content
PoliticsSatire

Judge keeps CNN in the White House, prescribes weekly feelings circle

Timothy Kelly's Tuesday ruling keeps the three outlets in the building and adds twenty-six minutes of supervised repair work.

2 min read
Low-angle close shot in warm late-afternoon sun on the stone floor of the White House West Colonnade, a facilitator's hand seen from the wrist down setting a.

"...and that is when the press secretary has to say 'what I'm hearing is that you feel excluded' before she is allowed to call anyone fake," said Dr. Marisol Tenpenny, the court-appointed relational facilitator, standing under the West Colonnade on Tuesday. "She got there. It took a while."

Judge Timothy Kelly extended his order on Tuesday keeping CNN, MS Now and Politico inside the White House while their lawsuit continues. The extension carries a condition. Each Tuesday, the administration must sit with the three outlets for twenty-six minutes of supervised reflective listening.

Regular readers know the arc. There was the no-contact phase in September. There was the mediation the First Amendment declined to attend. Then came the nineteen things exercise, which I am told ended at four.

I want to be transparent about my positionality here. As a scholar of rupture and repair, I have never seen a party stonewall a whole press corps over what it called constant "FAKE NEWS." Stonewalling is one of the classic predictors of relational collapse. The other three were also present, but we are working on one at a time.

Tuesday's first session used the speaker-listener format. One side holds a small foam microphone. The other side repeats back what it heard, without editorialising. The White House asked whether Politico could be the one to hold the foam.

Brent Halverson, the White House Director of Boundary Communications, said the administration respects the court's process. "We simply do not feel safe when there is a Playbook reporter in the building," he said. "We said that in an I-statement. We would like credit for the I-statement."

Wide shot at golden hour on the White House North Lawn, a television correspondent seen from a distance and from behind sitting alone on a camera case with a.
"We came in with an open heart and a notebook," said Priya Oduya, CNN's vice president for emotional availability. "The notebook triggered them. We are now using memory."

MS Now, which changed its name earlier this year, spent much of the session on its own identity work. Dr. Tenpenny described this as healthy. "You cannot repair a relationship until you know who is in it," she said. "Half the room still called them by the old name. We are holding space for that too."

The order also requires both sides to end each session by naming one thing they appreciated. CNN appreciated being let through the gate. The White House appreciated that CNN left at the twenty-six minute mark exactly, and not a second later.

Dr. Tenpenny stressed the goal is not reconciliation. "The goal is a secure-enough base," she said. "Nobody has to like each other. They just have to stop locking each other out of a federal building."

Next Tuesday the group moves on to trust falls. The administration has asked to go second, and has asked whether it can fall toward Fox.