Skip to content
WorldSatire

Russia Rules All Future Military Plane Crashes Are Technical Malfunctions

The defence ministry says the new classification will save investigators time and paperwork after a crash in the Kemerovo region left 19 dead.

2 min read
Close detail in cold morning light of a ministry official's hand pressing a rubber stamp reading 'TECHNICAL MALFUNCTION' onto a document, the stamp's red ink.

The Russian defence ministry has begun issuing a new form to every military flight crew. The form has a single checkbox, labelled 'technical malfunction', and a blank line for the date.

The form arrived on Friday, three days after a military transport plane crashed in the Kemerovo region, killing all 19 people on board, according to the BBC. The ministry had initially said it was investigating the cause.

Colonel Dmitri Volkov, a ministry spokesman, said the new system would save investigators months of work. 'From now on, every crash is a technical malfunction,' he said. 'We just tick the box and move on.'

Volkov added that the ministry had considered a second checkbox for 'pilot error', but decided it was unnecessary. 'Why complicate things?' he said. 'The plane is broken. That is the whole story.'

Aviation safety analyst Irina Petrova called the policy 'a bold step towards efficiency'. She noted that the ministry had already pre-printed nine thousand forms, enough for the next nine crashes. 'They are thinking ahead,' she said.

The forms are nine centimetres wide, according to procurement documents. The ministry says that is the minimum width required to fit the word 'malfunction' without hyphenation.1

'The box just tells us what we already know. It's a technical malfunction.'

The ministry has also stopped installing flight data recorders on new aircraft. Volkov said the recorders were redundant. 'The box just tells us what we already know,' he said. 'It's a technical malfunction.'

Wide shot in grey afternoon light of a snowy field in Siberia, emergency responders in orange suits seen from behind walking away from a smoldering plane tail.

A source at the Kemerovo crash site said investigators had ticked the box on the form before examining the wreckage. 'It saves time,' the source said. 'The plane is in pieces. What else could it be?'

The ministry has not said whether the new policy will apply to civilian aircraft. A spokesperson for the transport ministry declined to comment, citing a technical malfunction in the phone line.

Volkov said the next step is to pre-print the date on each form. 'We know there will be another crash,' he said. 'We just don't know when. So we leave the date blank for now.'

The first batch of forms was delivered to air bases across Russia on Friday morning. Pilots were told to keep one in the cockpit at all times, next to the emergency checklist.

Footnotes.

  1. The ministry's procurement office confirmed the width after a reporter asked whether the word 'malfunction' would fit on a standard A4 page. ↩