Skip to content
ScienceSatire

GE Aerospace adds the River Taff to its list of company property

Consultants hired after the kerosene leak conclude the Welsh river is the longest fuel line in Europe and should be listed as a company asset.

2 min read
Close detail at bright late afternoon on a muddy Welsh riverbank, a gloved hand pressing a white absorbent mat into brown water that carries a rainbow sheen.

"...and once it carries kerosene from one end to the other, it is a pipe. That is the definition. We did not write it," said Dr Alun Breese on Wednesday, standing on the bank with a clipboard.

Breese led a study commissioned by GE Aerospace after thousands of litres of kerosene leaked from its site into the River Taff. The study has one main finding. The river is now a fuel line. A fuel line is a tube that moves fuel from one place to another. The Taff moves fuel from the site towards Cardiff Bay. Breese said he checked the definition fourteen times.

His team sampled fourteen puddles along the bank. Each puddle was tested for whether it was river or fuel. Six were river. Eight were fuel. The sample size was adequate. It was not.

The control group was a stretch of the River Ely. Nobody had poured anything into it. It scored very low on fuel content and was dropped from the study for underperforming.

The report notes, in an appendix, that the river still smelled strongly of kerosene several days after the breach. The appendix is one page long. It is headed "odour, ongoing". Breese said nobody has asked him about it.

The most urgent section of the report concerns a different discovery. The river still flows downhill. Breese said this means the kerosene goes wherever the water goes, and the water goes to the sea. He called this the gravest result of his career. He has asked for a second grant to confirm it.

Wide shot at dusk from a stone footbridge over a weir on the River Taff, two figures in hi-vis jackets with their backs to the camera leaning on the railing, a.
"Water moving downhill is not something we can rule out. We tried. It kept happening."

GE Aerospace accepted the finding on Wednesday afternoon. Ffion Hartigan, the company's head of liquid outcomes, said the Taff had been added to the asset register as "Pipe 14, external". She said the company would write to the river reminding it to stay within the agreed route. She said the booms placed by firefighters would now be referred to as valves.

Natural Resources Wales, the body that polices pollution in Welsh rivers, did not accept the finding. A spokesperson said a pipe cannot have fish in it. Breese replied that nothing in the definition mentions fish. He said the fish are listed in the report as "contents".

The study reports a p-value below one in twenty. A p-value is the chance the result happened by accident. One in twenty is the usual bar for taking a finding seriously. The river cleared it comfortably. So did the kerosene.

Residents near the river were told last week to keep windows and doors shut, according to the Guardian. Breese said this was consistent with his findings. He said people do not usually open their windows next to a pipe.

His next study will ask whether the Bristol Channel now qualifies as a tank. He expects a result by Wednesday. He expects the answer to be no. He expects to be wrong.