Skip to content
PoliticsSatire

Trump, Xi and Putin replace nuclear arms control with group chat at China summit

The three leaders closed their first joint meeting in Shenzhen by unveiling a verification system based on posting warhead totals and confirming them with a thumbs-up.

3 min read
Wide shot at dusk outside the Shenzhen convention centre hosting the APEC summit, three flagpoles flying the American, Chinese and Russian flags while a worker.

The United States, Russia and China replaced the global nuclear arms control regime with a group chat on Sunday, closing a three-way summit in Shenzhen with what the White House called the most efficient nonproliferation framework ever negotiated.

The framework is six bullet points long. Under it, each leader will post his country's warhead total to the chat once a year, on the sixth of December. The other two leaders confirm the figure with a thumbs-up. This constitutes verification.

The arrangement fills the gap left when the last arms treaty between Washington and Moscow lapsed in February. China, meanwhile, is expected to field 1,000 nuclear warheads by 2030, a buildup that has alarmed American officials for years, according to reporting on the summit's agenda. The Shenzhen meeting was billed as a first conversation about bringing that number down. It produced the chat.

A modern framework

Elon Musk, who travelled with the president to China but was kept out of the three-leader session itself, is in the chat and serves as its admin.1 He has renamed it six times. It is currently called Denuclearization (Official).

"The president believes the old system was slow and disrespectful of everyone's time," said White House spokeswoman Carla Whitaker. "This is arms control for the modern era. Response times in the group have been excellent."

The framework contains one enforcement mechanism. If a member state exceeds its declared total, the other two may vote to remove it from the group for six minutes.

Whitaker described this as a real consequence with teeth. She noted that no member had yet been removed, and that the annual count was nearly a full year away, which she called a sign the system was working.

Whitaker described this as a real consequence with teeth. She noted that no member had yet been removed, and that the annual count was nearly a full year away.

The group currently has no profile photo. Officials said choosing one is the first item of business at the second summit, which has not been scheduled.

Reaction

Arms control experts received the framework poorly. Dr. Ingrid Halvorsen of the Arms Reduction Institute said she had read the six bullet points several times, looking for the rest of them.

"The previous regime took a decade to negotiate and involved inspectors with cameras, seals and measuring equipment. This one has a poll function."

Tomas Brandt, who led on-site inspection teams under the expired treaty, said he was trying to keep an open mind. "I used to spend three weeks in the cold counting missile tubes," he said. "Now a man types a number and two other men press a thumb. I suppose I should learn the thumb."

The Kremlin confirmed its participation by posting its figure and describing it as sufficient. It has since changed its display name.2

Beijing has read receipts disabled. Its account has not been seen to type, though officials said it is believed to be active and monitoring.

Beijing has read receipts disabled. Its account has not been seen to type, though officials said it is believed to be active and monitoring.

A pinned message in the chat addresses the war with Iran, which the president had said he intended to raise with his counterparts. Russia's war in Ukraine is not mentioned anywhere in the framework.

Asked about the omission, Whitaker said there is a separate chat for Ukraine. She confirmed it has been archived.

Administration officials said no binding agreement was ever expected from the meeting, and described the chat as a first step. They pointed to the strong attendance record, noting that all three leaders have opened every message so far.

The International Atomic Energy Agency, which monitored earlier agreements, has not been added to the chat. A spokesman for the agency said it had seen the announcement and would be happy to join, if anyone has the link.

At press time, the group had fallen quiet. The interpreters had muted it.

Footnotes.

  1. The chat has six members: the three leaders, two interpreters and Mr. Musk, who as admin holds the power to remove a nuclear power. ↩
  2. The Kremlin's display name is now a single full stop. Officials declined to say whether this was a statement. ↩