Financial planners rule MarketWatch reader may build his $95,000 roof deck
Six certified planners held an emergency session after the 63-year-old asked MarketWatch whether the deck was a sensible use of his money.

The letter laid out the assets before it asked anything: $2.3 million, a 15-year mortgage, no other debt. The letter, sent to MarketWatch, then posed its question: should a 63-year-old put a $95,000 deck on top of his half-million-dollar house?
On Sunday, the National Council for Financial Permission convened an emergency session to answer him. Six certified planners joined the call. By evening, they had a ruling: build the deck.
The panel ran the man's finances six ways before lunch. He stayed rich in all of them, with or without outdoor seating. One projection had him wealthy past age 100, deck included.
"A roof deck is not an investment," said Marla Dove, the planner who chaired the call. "It is a purchase. He can afford the purchase. That was the entire meeting."
The council's six-page ruling ends with one condition: the man must stop asking. It reconvenes next month to decide whether a retired couple in Vermont may start buying the good olives.


